Why Sourdough? Why Soaked? Why Even Bother?

A few weeks ago, my friend Liz left this comment on my “Seven Essential Tools for Baking” post.

Liz's bread question

I answered her briefly in a comment there but promised her that I’d write a fuller response because I think it’s a great question!

Why Even Bother?

First let’s start with why even bother at all with baking anything other than a standard, mainstream recipe.  It’s well-known and accepted in the mainstream nutritional world that it’s better for you to eat baked goods made with whole wheat flour rather than white flour.  Whole wheat flour generally has its fiber and nutrients intact and is certainly more nutritious than white flour, which has had the germ and bran stripped from it.  Most white flour is enriched with vitamins and minerals but that doesn’t make up for the fact that it’s a highly processed food. Consequently, we have all been told, “Eat your whole grains!”

The problem with whole wheat flour (and all whole grains) is that it is also full of phytic acid.  Phytic acid is a substance commonly called an “anti-nutrient”.  Most seeds, grains, nuts, and beans have phytic acid in their outer shell.  Its function is to keep the seed/grain/bean from disintegrating until it sprouts after it’s planted.  (White flour doesn’t have this because the bran is removed.)  Phytic acid blocks the absorption of nutrients in your gut, making whole grains difficult to digest for many people. There are two ways to neutralize the phytic acid – either by using sprouted flour (store-bought or homemade) or by soaking the whole grain flour in acidic water for at least 12 hours.  (Generally speaking, you add whey/yogurt or some kind of vinegar to make the water acidic.)  Sourdough starter is acidic and the long rise of sourdough bread serves the same function as soaking your flour. We’ve discovered that in our family, our guts function much better when we are eating soaked or sourdough bread.

Soaking/sourdough not only neutralizes the phytic acid, it also does some predigestion so that the bread is easier for your body to digest.  I’ve read stories of some people’s gluten intolerance going away once they started to eat exclusively sprouted/soaked/sourdough products.

028 (800x533) (2)soaked bagels

I know it seems like a lot of work to either take the extra step of using soaking or sourdough when making bread.  What finally pushed me to make this a regular part of our diet was reading a quote from Sally Fallon (author of Nourishing Traditions and a rock star in the traditional foods world), in which she said something like, “If my choice was between unsoaked/unsprouted whole wheat bread or all-white-flour bread, I’d chose the white bread.”*  I thought, “Wow!  If Sally Fallon is saying that she’d actually eat white flour, then I’d better look into this a little bit further.”  At this point, I don’t use whole wheat flour or any other whole grains without doing an overnight soak or a long sourdough rise.  (And by “don’t use”, what I really mean is “hardly ever ever.”  For example, I do occasionally make our whole wheat pizza crust recipe without soaking it if I forget to start it soaking the night before.)

Why Choose Sourdough?  Why Choose Soaked?

So, if I’ve convinced you (and I hope I have), that its worth the time and effort to neutralize the phytic acid in your whole grains, your next decision is how to do it.

Choose sourdough if you:

  • like the flexibility of a long (if unpredictable) rise time
  • like the complex flavor of a more sour bread
  • want a very traditional way of making bread
  • like more dense, chewy bread
  • want to minimize the number of ingredients you use in your baking
  • want to completely eliminate commercial yeast from your diet (as many do)

Choose soaked if  you:

  • need a shorter, more predictable rising time (because you’ll be using commercial yeast)
  • prefer the flavor of “regular” bread over sourdough bread
  • want to produce a lighter, fluffier bread
  • don’t want the trouble of maintaining a sourdough starter
  • want to improve the nutritional quality of your baked goods without adding sour flavor

So, Liz, to answer your question, choose soaking your grains!  I choose one or the other based on a variety of factors, including what I want to make and how much time I have to make it.

031 (800x534)soaked whole wheat sandwich bread


Although I started baking the majority of our bread at the beginning of 2011, it wasn’t until later in 2012 that I entered the world of soaking grains.  Over the past couple years, I have been hard at work, adapting many recipes to meet our needs.  I’ve shared a few of them with you already and have more to come.

Here are my recipes for whole wheat sourdough bread, black pepper oregano whole wheat sourdough crackers, soaked [mostly] whole wheat sandwich bread, soaked whole wheat pumpkin muffins, and soaked granola.

Coming up in the next few weeks: recipes for soaked bagels, sourdough rolls, soaked whole wheat pizza crust dough, plus how to soak beans and lentils.


*Of course, I can’t find the place online where I read that quote so you’ll just have to trust my hazy memory on that one!  It was something like that anyway.

Here’s an example of what you could buy for sprouted wheat flour.  I haven’t bought it before because, as you can see, it’s quite expensive – about four times as much as I pay for my locally-milled regular whole wheat flour.  It’s an easy choice for me to either soak my flour or use sourdough.

See this post for more about phytic acid, including its chemical makeup.

This entry was posted in baking and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Why Sourdough? Why Soaked? Why Even Bother?

  1. Lisa S says:

    Thanks! I’ve been thinking I should start making my own bread. My friend Janna mentioned that commercial bread is made with all sorts of chemicals to get fast rise times and fluffy results. And I really should have known that without her telling me, but somehow having someone lay it out like that made sigh and say, ok, ok, I’ll try to make my own bread. I’m not such a fan of sour doughs either, not as a main go-to bread, so I looked up a multi-grain sandwich bread on the Fresh Loaf. Now, that website scares me a little. Those people are a bit obsessed, I think, though there is no denying they turn out beautiful things. And the vocabulary. Autolyse? Poolish? But I found one recipe I thought fit our sandwich bread bill, and with your recent posts about making bread, decided to try it. It’s a soaker, though just with milk. Maybe as I go and get braver I’ll try things like yogurt or whey. I’d love to share the results with you, can I send pictures somehow? I need to keep practicing, this if it’s going to become our main bread, but a first attempt was positive. And I never knew you could make bread in a dutch oven. I’m going to try that next! After I season my cast iron dutch oven. Thanks, Laura!

    • Laura says:

      Lisa – Yay for you for making bread! 🙂 You’re right that I totally skipped a step in the “Why Bother” question. As in, I probably should also write a “Why bother to bake your own bread at all” post because Janna is totally right the commercial bread is chock full of unpronounceable chemicals that just aren’t good for our bodies. You can buy good bread (from Atwater’s for example) but it’s so expensive. We’d eat ourselves out of our budget quickly if we were eating that bread all the time. As baking bread, yes, it’s really easy to fall into the rabbit hole of obsessiveness and I’ve tried to keep myself near the top of the hole at least! And, not to toot my own horn or anything, my soaked sandwich bread recipe is SO easy, relatively fail-safe and a nice fluffy bread. You could try that if you want to try a non-intimidating soaking recipe. Be sure to click on the link for the original recipe. That blogger has all sorts of pictures to go with her instructions. And, I’d love to see pictures of your bread! Maybe have Carter post them on Facebook? Or definitely you can email them to me too!

      • Lisa S says:

        I have continued to make bread, even started one in the dutch oven. That’s just a white bread, but the last time I made it I added a bit of olive oil and rosemary and it was just like our favorite bread from Atwater’s. I’m still working on the multi-grain recipe I got from The Fresh Loaf. It tastes great, even if the kids don’t like it once it cools down. It’s not getting as high as I’d like, but I need to figure out if I need smaller loaf pans or if something is wrong with the recipe. It tells me I should have 3 lbs of dough, and I only end up with just over 2 lbs. I think I’m ready to stop buying my bread from the store (though I did just buy potato hamburger rolls, the kids love them with nutella). Thanks for the posts, they are inspiring. Oh, yeah, I had a question, too. So, while I’m not a fan of sour doughs, I’m beginning to wonder if all sour doughs are equal. Are some not as sour as others? What would influence that? Flours? Starter types, or how much starter is used? Just wondering what you know or what your thoughts are. Thanks!

      • Laura says:

        Lisa – I’m so glad to hear that you’re having such success with baking bread! My bread loaves are usually around 1.25 pounds for my bread pans if that’s any help. You could try increasing the recipe by 25% and still make the same number of loaves to see if that gets this big enough for what you’d like.

        And as for sourdough, you definitely can manipulate the sourness of your sourdough. This article has some ideas. Try searching “how to make sourdough bread less sour” and you’ll find lots of ideas. I like it pretty sour so I’ve never tried to manipulate that particular aspect. Different starters do have different flavors also, depending on what wild yeasts got into the starters as they were being started. My white starter definitely tastes different than my whole wheat. That could be due to the flour also. So, if you want to delve into this, I’m sure you could have lots of fun experimenting!

  2. Mom says:

    Beautiful loaves!

  3. Pingback: Caution: Disastrous Results Ahead | Salmon and Souvlaki

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s