This is my fourth post about 2015’s books for The Classics Club. I’ll be reading one classic book a month through 2018. Track what I’m reading for the Classics Club here. I’ll try not to include too many spoilers in my review but I may need to discuss some in order to fully review the book. I’ll warn you if I’m going to mention one.
Till We Have Faces: A Myth Retold by C.S. Lewis
I promise we were stopped at a stop light when I took this picture (as we went to the library to return the book).
- Year Published: 1956
- Reread? Or new to me?: new to me
- Number of Pages: 324
- Date Finished: just before the end of July
- Number of Days it took me to read it: ??
- Page/Day ratio: ??
- Will I reread this?: Maybe? See below.
Review:
Please forgive me for the briefness of this review. I’ve fallen WAY behind on reviewing my Classic Club books, although I have kept up with the reading. So I’m remembering my experience reading this from a few months ago.
I opened Till We Have Faces with great anticipation, having heard on a podcast that this book was one of three that should be taken to a desert island. A family member of mine also told me of how deeply she was affected by the story.
Sadly, for me – I was relatively unmoved. The story was sad, especially with the immensity of the mistakes made by everyone involved. I must confess, however, that I just didn’t find the deeper, life-impacting meaning in it. I did shed a few tears at the end but certainly wasn’t left pondering much of anything. I was oddly let down by this. I wanted it to be overwhelming, not underwhelming! What does this say about me? That I totally missed the point? That I wasn’t open to letting it affect me while I was reading it? Or perhaps just that we are all individuals and consequently have different responses to the same novel?
I am glad I read this but I don’t know if I will get around to the multiple readings recommended by the desert island podcast guest to really be able to absorb all I can from it.
How about you? If you’ve read this, were you in the “stone-hearted” camp when reading Till We Have Faces and consequently totally understand me? Or are you shocked and horrified at my lack of sensitivity to Lewis’s deeper message?
***************
Unfortunately, it’s too late to invite you to join me in reading the books that I read for August, September, October, and November. So perhaps you’d like to join me in reading Little Lord Fauntleroy by Frances Hodgson Burnett in December? I’ve read A Little Princess
and The Secret Garden
too many times to count but somehow haven’t read this one yet.
I see you watching me read a book at a stop light.
I hated this book! It was bleak and ugly and depressing and I didn’t get any deeper meaning out of it. It has been many years since I read it, and I have been looking forward to your review to see if I was just too immature to “get it” and if it was worth another read. I’m thinking no.
Well, I’m glad I’m not the only one who didn’t love it.
Pingback: Classics Club, Book #22: A Grief Observed (November 2015) | Salmon and Souvlaki