The Practice of Assigning Positive Intent

I first read about this life-giving practice here.

A gentle answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger.  Proverbs 15:1

A discipline I’ve been trying to adopt recently has been the practice of “assigning positive intent.”  Basically it’s just assuming that the other person has positive intent in their actions towards you, rather than negative.  This has been particularly helpful to me in parenting our rather intense almost-3-year-old Ellie.  If I assume that she’s doing XYZ not to drive me crazy or to be defiant and/or mean but rather because she genuinely wants to be with me, help me, be nice to her little brother (or whatever), then it helps me react to her in a more positive way myself.

Generally, it also helps diffuse the situation when I don’t respond negatively.  It’s always easier to escalate a response (as in if I figure out that the intent was actually negative) but much harder to scale it back.

Example #1:  A couple months ago, we were outside doing a bit of weeding and I said, “Ellie, we need to go inside and check to see if Baby Mark is awake [from his nap].”  By the time I had my shoes off, I realized that she had barged into the room, shouting.  Mark was, miraculously, still asleep and so I not-so-gently pulled her out of the room, chastising her for being noisy around her sleeping brother.  As her sweet face got sadder and sadder, I realized that she had thought I said, “Mark is awake,” and so had gone in to greet him as we always do when he wakes up from his nap.  I assumed the worst (maliciously wake up little brother) when I should have assumed the best (so fun to see my brother when he wakes up!).

Example #2:  Again, a couple months ago, Mark was just starting to be interested in toys and so I rather idly commented to the air that I needed to get some toys out for him.  Almost immediately Ellie disappeared, I assumed off to play.  A few minutes later, she was back in the kitchen with a toy that I knew had been upstairs.  Upstairs is generally off-limits to Ellie unless she’s with an adult and I started to chastise her about that.  But as the words were coming out of my mouth, I realized that she had gone up there to help me by finding a toy for Mark.  I managed to redirect my comments towards thanking her for her generous spirit and for treating her brother kindly.  Then we did talk about the upstairs rules but it was without squashing those good impulses!

I’m trying to do this in my relationships with other people too.  It’s far to easy to assume that the people we love the most are out to get us.  It’s too easy for me to jump to anger or defensiveness in my interactions with Nik when really, I should be assuming that ultimately, he’s on my side, that he loves me and wants the best for me.

On the parenting front, when I sense judgement coming from others (about our parenting choices), I’m trying to re-frame it in a way that says, “They really are just concerned about me and my kids and are trying to help me – even if the way they are trying to help is annoying or misguided.”  It helps me to feel less stressed myself about negative interactions if I can interpret them more positively.  (I should clarify that these negative experiences have, thankfully, been very rare.)

In any negative interaction, either with my family, friends, or strangers, I’ve found that if I respond in a manner that assumes positive intent on their part, it helps to move the interaction in a positive direction.

More times than not, I assume the worst and act according.  But every day, I’m trying to respond with a gentle answer, assuming the positive intent of the other, and it’s helping me to become a better parent, wife, and friend.

001 (800x800)It’s pretty easy to be positive when they’re being this cute! 🙂

This entry was posted in Ellie, Mark, parenting, reflecting. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to The Practice of Assigning Positive Intent

  1. wow…its like you took my thoughts right out of my brain and typed them out for me. this has been heavy on my heart for quite sometime, and I feel like its a CONSTANT thing to keep it at the forefront of my mind. and that verse couldn’t be more true…whenever i react to Grace very strongly, or with sarcasm (hangs head in shame), she usually reacts back to me the same way. And then its a snowball effect….i get even more upset at her for acting yucky to me, when really I was being yucky in the first place. and I absolutely agree with you how its not just our kiddos that it happens to! The sentence you wrote about Nik is something I usually have to remind myself to do as well!! Thanks for taking time to blog, I wish I could be as motivated!! :/ love love love this blog, LOVE your kiddos and I LOVE you!!!

    • Laura says:

      That snowball effect is so hard to escape, Rach! And you’re right – it’s pretty easy to blame the child for disrespect when we started it ourselves (or certainly helped it along). I LOVE you too!!

  2. janaliebermann says:

    Admittedly, I don’t have the parenting challenges you have 🙂 but, I’ve been working on this idea all of my life, but didn’t really frame it the same way you did. I call it my “naive” personality — I generally think the best of things. My naivety (if I spelled that right) has gotten me into some really unique and genuinely funny situations. I’ve tried (sometimes with very little effect) to teach people that I am not out to get them!!! Still a work in progress. Thanks for your post! You said it better than I could!

  3. Eliz. K says:

    Hi Laura,
    It was nice to meet you and your little ones in real life today!

    I always enjoy your posts, but this one is extra-good. Thanks for posting about it!

    Hope you all had a lovely afternoon!

  4. Pingback: Classics Club, Book #23: Little Lord Fauntleroy (December 2015) | Salmon and Souvlaki

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s